Peer Reviews

1. Is there a clear point of view? (position)
Yes, Tiger may be coming back too soon
2. Does the Op-Ed state the problem and solution simply?
Yes, obviously talking about Tiger Wood's comeback
3. Does the piece address the counter arguments?
Tough to address counter arguments in a drawing
4. Is the Op-Ed interesting?
Yes. good drawing and humorous
5. Are the paragraphs organized logically?
It's a cartoon
6. Does each paragraph develop an idea to support the thesis?
Drawing proves its point
7. Is the writing clear?
The cartoon is clear


1. Is there a clear point of view? (position)
Yes, sign Joe Mauer
2. Does the Op-Ed state the problem and solution simply?
Yes, need to give him a big contract
3. Does the piece address the counter arguments?
Yes, the Twins may do fine without him, but he's a hometown star that we wouldn't want to lose
4. Is the Op-Ed interesting?
Yes, lots of good lines
5. Are the paragraphs organized logically?
Yes
6. Does each paragraph develop an idea to support the thesis?
Yes
7. Is the writing clear?
Yes, easy to follow